Featured / USMNT

Recap: Jamaica 2–1 USA

On Friday night, the USMNT resumed World Cup qualifying against Jamaica, in Kingston. The team hoped to come away with a point at minimum, but instead left with nothing. They must hope to reverse things in Columbus on Tuesday night, or their chances at qualifying for the World Cup Finals could be in jeopardy.

Clint Dempsey made a surprise start, as did Michael Parkhurst, who came in for Steve Cherundolo, out with a training injury. Carlos Bocanegra was among the subs, with Clay Goodson taking his place. Geoff Cameron and Fabian Johnson rounded out the defense; Kyle Beckerman, Maurice Edu, and Jermaine Jones made up a defensive-looking midfield; and Jozy Altidore and Herculez Gomez ran the forward line in front of Dempsey.

First half

The U.S. could not have started better, scoring inside of 36 seconds. Taking the kickoff forward immediately, Maurice Edu made his best contribution of the evening, by slipping a ball to Gomez up the inside right channel. Gomez was challenged strongly, but managed to keep his feet, and the ball, too. His snap shot was saved by the keeper, but it rebounded back to Gomez’s feet, and he put it back in again, only for a retreating defender to get down and block. This time, the ball deflected centrally, where a late-arriving Clint Dempsey calmly slotted the ball home.

The Jamaican fans were stunned, and what had been a raucous crowd was quieted. The U.S. kept control for a time without ever doing very much, and it was becoming clear that, despite the early goal, the U.S. was missing Landon Donovan and Michael Bradley. Midfield play was especially disjointed, and the Jamaicans grew into the game somewhat, though without creating any chances of note.

On 24 minutes, a theme of the game would be revealed, as the U.S. midfield, too slow, fouled a Jamaican attacker running with the ball through the center of the U.S. half. Kyle Beckerman, unable to keep up with Rodolph Austin, attempted a tackle but took the man instead of the ball, 25 yards from goal. Austin stepped up to take the free kick, and his shot was low and straight at the wall. Unfortunately, instead of rebounding, the ball merely deflected through the legs of Beckerman, and scooted low to Tim Howard’s left, into the goal.

After the goal, the Jamaicans asserted control of the match, with the U.S. doing a lot of chasing and closing down, but little effective tackling or attacking. There were more fouls than decent chances, and the U.S., when it did have the ball, was careless with it. The half closed with a few half-chances for the U.S., Clint Dempsey having his sliding shot saved after good work from Michael Parkhurst on the right, but the teams finished level at the break.

Second Half

The second period opened without much change. The Jamaicans continued to dominate possession in the midfield without creating much, and the U.S. did little when it had the ball. Instead, more and more fouls were committed, with the play getting choppy on both sides.

On 58 minutes, Beckerman was pulled in favor of Danny Williams, perhaps in the hope of injecting some pace into the U.S. midfield. In the 62nd, it was Maurice Edu’s turn to make a clumsy lunge on a Jamaican attacker, setting up a free kick on the Jamaican left, some 20 yards from goal. This time, the wall did its job, but Luton Shelton’s free kick was of the highest quality, sailing a hair’s-breadth over the wall and pinging off Howard’s right post and in. It was an excellent goal, but one that did not need to happen.

Jurgen Klinsmann waited another 10 minutes before bringing on Brek Shea and Terrence Boyd for Altidore and Edu. The U.S.’s play improved somewhat as a result, but there was to be no magical comeback. Gomez took it on himself to make things happen, and created a half-chance, chipping the ball over the Jamaican defense to Dempsey, who was whistled for handball as he took the ball down with his arm. A minute later, Shea got the ball to the left endline, and his lofted cross was met by Dempsey, who could only head over under pressure. The game petered out from there with several minutes of extra time resulting in no chances of note for either team.


Look for our full analysis and player ratings on Monday morning, but the initial reaction must center on the U.S. midfield. With little width and not enough creativity in the center, the U.S. couldn’t compete in the middle third, giving the Jamaicans too much of the ball. That possession led, in turn, to cheap fouls too close to the U.S. goal and two set-piece goals. Klinsmann’s substitutions were too little and definitely too late, and one would have to expect a more attacking starting lineup on Tuesday in the return game in Columbus. A win is a must, or the U.S. may face the prospect of unexpected elimination from qualifying if it can’t win out in its final two group games.



  1. A midfield of Edu, Beckerman and Jones was a goddamn insult. And really, who was surprised? That’s 3 DMids for gods sake. You might as well clone Brian Carroll and start 3 of him in the midfield against Toronto.
    Obviously we missed Bradley, but all that did was make starting Torres a must. I like Klinsmann, but I am not sure what he was expecting. Those 3 players aren’t even that great most of the other time, they all are average more often than not.
    But jesus, I just cant get over starting those 3.

  2. Eli Pearlman-Storch says:

    Kyle Beckerman is atrociously bad. Just the worst. Fire him from the US. Is that a thing?

  3. Watching the USMNT struggle to find offensive flow vs Jamaica reminded me a lot of the Union’s problems. Neither have a central playmaker with vision and skill. Both have a tough time getting service to the strikers. And frustrated fans of both think an under-sized, over-hyped Torres is the answer.

    • James "4-3-3" Forever says:

      Sadly for the Nats they cant simply trade or sign a better one. And Holden’s knees are still recovering. So it sounds ridiculous but Torres is still our best option. There is no reason to ever play 2 DMids like that again. And they’re not even above average DMids. Torres needs to play.
      Either that, or hell call up someone from the MLS with youth and promise like Farfan, or start Corona. Because to play those 3 players again should never happen.

  4. Nate Emeritz says:

    I’d like to see Donovan in the central playmaking role.
    UPSIDES: 1- he can distribute and run at defenders, 2- there is enough talent to fill in on the wings and up fron that he can leave his traditional roles there, 3- it could provide structure for the team to continue building on the movement that Klinsmann has instituted, 4- LD could transition into that role and possibly prolong his usefulness on USMNT by relying more on distribution and less on speed as he gets older and loses pace, 5- it could allow for more interactions between LD and Dempsey, which is the USMNT’s best attacking duo, than when LD is on the outside.
    DOWNSIDES: 1- it would be a new role for him, 2- he has proven to be most dangerous attacking from the wings, 3- setting a player in the middle of the currently open formation could discourage or stagnate the movement that Klinsmann has instituted.
    As far as his alleged fading interest in soccer, this new role could challenge and invigorate him, or it could require the dedication that he doesn’t currently possess… toss up.
    I think the UPSIDES are sufficiently probable to outweigh the DOWNSIDES that it’s worth experimenting. In formation, I would use a 4-3-3 with LD in front of Bradley and Jones and behind Dempsey, Altidore, and[Gomez/Shea/Bedoya/Torres?]. I also think they need a CAM, and I’m not sold on Torres as a playmaker in international competition.

    • I would love to see this with Dempsey and Shea beside him and bradley just behind him running down balls, but unfortunately some of those guys were hurt and we need a second option, I don’t think Torres is cutting it, he disappears to easily( and I’m trying to give him the benefit that the last few games he hasn’t had much support going forward)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *