Featured / Player ratings / Union

Analysis & player ratings: Union 1-1 FC Dallas

Photo: Daniel Gajdamowicz

The good news first.

The Union grabbed a road point in Frisco, Texas, their first in three trips to FC Dallas. Chase Harrison not only survived his first MLS start, but he also fought through the barrage of George John and Andrew Jacobson shaped missiles hurled at him over the 90 minutes, making important saves and showing strength in the air.

Now the bad news.

The rest of the match.

Lahoud? La-why?

In his Union debut Michael Lahoud played more minutes than he had in the previous 10 matches for Chivas USA. Traveling east in exchange for Union captain Danny Califf, it seemed unlikely that Lahoud would crack the Union’s already crowded midfield, but with only one training session under his belt, Peter Nowak handed the Union’s newest player a start in Frisco, Texas.

It was a decision that appeared questionable with the announcement of the team sheet and only grew more incomprehensible during the match, with Nowak calling the player to the sideline a handful of times in the first half just to explain his positioning and role on the field. Coming off their most composed performance of the season against New York Red Bulls, Nowak’s gamble on Lahoud led to a midfield that was disjointed and confused, committing turnovers with reckless abandon and failing to connect on even the simplest of passes.

That was not a 4-3-3

Keon Daniel? At striker? Really? Was it his two glaring misses against the Red Bulls that earned him the role alongside Mwanga and Pajoy up top? If the Union were truly serious about giving a 4-3-3 the chance to be successful, Josue Martinez would have earned the start up top, with Daniel dropping into midfield at the expense of Lahoud. The attacking trio that did so well to pressure the Schalke defense represents the Union’s best threesome at the moment and should have been deployed were the Union taking the formation seriously.

The left-footed Daniel was at a complete loss playing forward on the right wing. With the brand new Michael Lahoud tasked with creating out of the midfield, the organization of the Union was a complete shambles, and the pipeline of service to Mwanga and Pajoy ran dry.

You call that defense?

While Danny Califf was out in California, preparing to help Chivas USA knock off the Galaxy for the first time in five years with his Man of the Match performance, the Union defense was beaten, battered and torn apart by a lone striker. With Dallas playing narrow through the midfield and only Blas Perez to worry about up top, the Union still failed to converge on the danger posed by former Union man Andrew Jacobson. Deployed in a more attacking role against the Union, Jacobson had time and space at the top of the box to dictate play. It was his run in the 5th minute that forced Harrison into action and resulted in the corner kick that yielded Dallas’ opener.

And it was all preventable. His first game as full time captain did not see the end of Carlos Valdes’ upfield ramblings, and he was caught far out of position by Jacobson after being slow to recover from a full field run. With a first time goalkeeper behind him and the 5’8″ Sheanon Williams at his side, Valdes must give his attacking forays a rest and focus on shutting the door at the back.

Moves further up the field served to destabilize the defense as the constantly rotating midfield trio of Lahoud, Gabriel Gomez and Brian Carroll did not do enough to shield the defense, with Michael Farfan particularly exposed on the right wing. Defensive cover improved when Keon Daniel dropped back into the midfield, but where the Union had taken the match to the Red Bulls, they lacked the energy and tenacity to press Dallas and subsequently dropped too deep in defense, making the job easier for the hosts.

Player Ratings

Chase Harrison – 6.5

Made up for a few nervy moments in the early going with a confident, physical second half performance. A more established goalkeeper would have gotten calls Harrison did not, and he had to endure a battering all night. For all the contact he received, the fact that only one whistle was blown is a shocking indictment of MLS officiating, especially considering the blatant nature of Jacobson’s late game body blow on Harrison. But for the debutant, whatever does not kill you makes you stronger, and he grew in confidence throughout the match. If he is able to shake off the bumps and bruises he earned on Saturday, the Union coaching staff should not hesitate to call his number again, if MacMath’s injury delays his return another week.

Michael Farfan – 4.5

The deficits in his defensive game were exposed by the more technical FC Dallas side. Got skinned down the right flank on multiple occasions with Dallas easily controlling the center of the park and then spreading the ball wide to the lively Bryan Leyva. It’s hard to lay too much of the blame at the feet of the makeshift fullback, but it was not his best day at the office as he was forced to spend more time retreating than pushing forward. Will be eager to see his brother return from injury as he will be itching to get back into the midfield where he is most comfortable. Pushing forward, Farfan is still the Union’s most dangerous one-on-one threat, and the need to defend undeniably hampers his creativity. Did manage to force Hartman into a diving save when he cut inside of two men and unleashed a powerful left-footed drive.

Sheanon Williams – 5.5

It is hard to imagine that Williams can survive the whole season playing center back. He’s forced to throw his whole body into every aerial challenge to climb above strikers who are consistently 4-8 inches taller. With the midfield sputtering in front of him and his partner looking for work too high up the pitch, Williams spent more time chasing Blas Perez than he would have wanted. He still shows his lack of center back experience at the MLS level at times, especifically when it comes to stepping up too quickly and allowing an attacker to race in behind, but he continued to show 100 percent commitment to the cause. His effort and vocal leadership were among the few bright spots for the Union.

Carlos Valdes – 4

Not the match the Union would have hoped from their now full-time captain. Jacobson’s early run left Valdes for dead in the 5th minute when the Colombian failed to fully recover from an ill-advised run up field. With his team, and specifically his defense, needing a strong veteran presence at the back, Valdes was less than his usual confident, assured self. He took too many chances in attack and did not marshal the backline with his usual authority. Valdes should recover in time for Toronto from the gash he received over his left eye late in the match, but if he doesn’t, the Union will be in for a nervy 90 minutes at BMO Field.

Ray Gaddis – 7

If he keeps up his play, Gaddis will force his way into both the Rookie of the Year and Union Player of the Year discussions. Again deployed out of position at left back, Gaddis shut the door on the normally dangerous Jackson and continued to fearlessly bomb forward in attack. Despite finding joy down their own left flank, Dallas kept looking for Jackson, but the Union rookie won the battle all night, showing composure in defense and smarts when he looked to facilitate the attack out of the back when possible. Only Sheanon Williams completed more passes than the rookie fullback, who shows no nerves or hesitation on the ball. Even in his brief development this season, Gaddis has added physicality to his game, and the combination of pace and power already make him a difficult matchup for anyone in MLS.

Brian Carroll – 3.5

Less than a week after putting in a Man of the Match-caliber performance against New York, Carroll was MIA in a big way in Dallas. Not only did he fail to provide a passing outlet for the defense and midfield, he was also caught in possession deep in his own half, a major no-no for a holding midfielder. Defensively, he let the normally defensive-minded Andrew Jacobson find space aplenty at the top of the Union box. If the Dallas midfielder was known for his finishing, Dallas would have almost certainly secured all three points.

Michael Lahoud – 2

Had absolutely no business being on the pitch for the Union and did little to justify his selection. Showed a good motor as he cruised around the pitch, from side to side, popping up all over the place, but rarely where he was needed. As one of only three midfielders deployed to begin the match, the Union coaching staff put their trust in Lahoud to catalyze the offense, and he simply was not up to the task. The majority of that blame falls on Nowak’s shoulders for the controversial selection, but rather than play simple, composed soccer, Lahoud tried to do too much, forcing his passes and delaying on the ball. After three violent, dangerous fouls, the Union were lucky that they were able to exchange Lahoud for Martinez early in the second half, since a better referee would not have hesitated to send him off.

Gabriel Gomez – 5

It’s a good thing Gomez scored a goal with his final touch of the match, since before that fortuitous play, he had been a virtual bystander. With Dallas flooding the middle of the field with Jacobson, Hernandez and Marcelin all looking to take up space in the heart of the pitch, Gomez was completely overrun and resorted to over-dribbling and pumping the ball aimlessly up field. For the Union to have any success, they cannot have a central midfielder completing only 63% of his passes for a total of an unacceptably meager 19 completions in 58 minutes.

Danny Mwanga – 3.5

Spent too much time trying to be a target forward and not enough time trying to be himself. Showed back-to the-ball well, drawing fouls and playing quick passes back into the midfield, but for Mwanga to convince Unions fans that he has his confidence back, he will need to square up on a defense and run at them. He did none of that Saturday. For all the good things he does, like showing physicality and making clearing runs for his midfielders, Mwanga’s lack of cutting edge is keeping him from showing up his doubters. Until he rediscovers that striker’s selfishness and bags a couple of goals, the questions about his play will linger.

Lionard Pajoy – 3.5

Showed some fancy footwork late in the game that nearly set the table for the Union, but otherwise isolated himself and looked uninterested in attacking the defense. Like Mwanga, also failed to register a single shot over 90 minutes. When the Union are going all guns, they can afford for Pajoy to sit wide, creeping in to surprise the defense or pounce on a loose ball. But when they are struggling for possession and shape as mightily as they were against Dallas, he needs to come find the ball and look for work. It was not until the after the Union had equalized that he rose to this challenge. Once he did, he showed some silky skills on the ball, but it was too little too late.

Keon Daniel – 2.5

Likely shocked to hear his name called as a striker in the locker room, Daniel struggled to affect play up top. His passing was off the mark, he was too easily dispossessed, and he did not have any comfort with the midfield behind him. For the third week in a row, he was badly exposed on set piece defense.


Josue Martinez – 6

Should have started the match if the Union indeed wanted to play a 4-3-3. When he came on, Martinez helped to turn the match for the Union, showing drive and intent as he attacked the Dallas defense. Questions linger about his touch, as he misplaced simple passes to kill off what looked to be promising builds out of the midfield. With the Union needing a victory over hapless Toronto, the Union coaching staff should consider starting Martinez up top with Mwanga and Pajoy in order to take the game to Toronto early and often.

Amobi Okugo – 5.5 

Remains the only Union midfielder committed to one- and two-touch passing. He looked to keep the ball moving quickly and spread the field well, bringing the outside backs into play as the Union attacked. Some of the veterans in the starting XI would do well to regard the youngster as an example as he moved the ball quickly amongst his fellow midfielders before switching fields with consistent accuracy. Will rue his missed chance when he skewed Pajoy’s cutback wide in the final moments of the game, but should Gomez’s injury require him to miss time with the Union, Okugo has proven that he is capable and prepared to start.

Porfirio Lopez – 4.5

Made his return to the first team for the first time since March and did just enough to keep Dallas at bay. Was very fortunate that Kadlecik failed to notice his elbow to Blas Perez as it would have resulted in a definite ejection. The disciplinary committee likely will not miss the incident and the Union could be without Lopez when they travel to Toronto. While his play was enough on the night to see out the road draw, Lopez didn’t do enough to prove that he is more than an emergency defender.

Geiger Counter

Mark Kadlecik – 2

The type of performance to which MLS fans have unfortunately grown too accustomed. The speed of the match passed Kadlecik by and he never fully had a handle on proceedings. Made mistakes all over the pitch, and while he split his mistakes fairly evenly between both sides, it was an inadequate performance. Should have sent off Lahoud in the first half, yet somehow failed to notice his late, dangerous challenge on Pertuz, which ended the defender’s night through injury. Also managed to whistle only once as Dallas challenged Harrison late and physically in the air. Each of George John’s lunging efforts could have, and probably should have been called, but the real shocker is how Jacobson managed to drop a shoulder into the Union keeper’s chest in the late going without receiving so much as a foul.

Additionally, Kadlecik favors the overly histrionic, in your face style of refereeing most notably practiced by the man for which the Geiger Counter is named. Inappropriately aggressive, he appeared to lash out at contrite players, creating further chaos when a calming influence was needed.

Preferred lineup for Saturday’s match at Toronto FC


MacMath; Gaddis, Williams, Valdes, Garfan; Marfan, Carroll, Okugo; Mwanga, Pajoy, Martinez


  1. James "4-3-3" Forever says:

    Good points. These recent personnel decisions are bad enough by themselves. But throw in Nowaks weak (at best) tactical acumen and it seems like Nowak is more interested in fitting round pegs into square holes than he is playing to strengths.

  2. DarthLos117 says:

    Such an ungly game. Im at a loss. We should have easily beat Dallas if we fielded an competent lineup. How are they going to build chemistry if they are constantly being shuffled around and played out of position? It really is a shame what Nowak and the coaching staff is doing to some of our players. On behalf to the coaching staff, I want to apologize to Williams, M. Farfan and others for messing with your development and future, sorry guys.

  3. Is Adu not playing next match? Because if he’s healthy, he has to be starting. Kid was electric in the Red Bulls match. Martinez providing an energy sub later on.

  4. Nice analysis, although it really seems from reading PSP that doomsday is upon the Union. I think perhaps we might be forgetting that the team can develop and get better despite Nowak. I agree that Martinez looked really good out there and should get more opportunity. I like the lineup for next week except that I’m not ready to cast out Kai Herdling, or Freddy for that matter. One of them should be included in that midfield, Freddy gets my vote. Perhaps remove Okugo. Substitutions should be Okugo (for Carroll), Herdling (for Freddy), Hoffman (Pajoy). All under the ridiculous assumption that we retain the 4-3-3, are rational, have a lead on Toronto, and don’t get a red card or injury.

    • The Black Hand says:

      I would take a look at Amobi Okugo at CB, before I would play him as an outside MF. He has decent size and defends well. This would allow Shaenon to shift back to his RB role. I think that Valdez and Okugo could (possibly) be effective in the middle…maybe. Adu, Herdling, Daniel or Lahoud would all be better options at the outside mid, than Okugo…in my opinion.

      • James "4-3-3" Forever says:

        Or we can use some of this allocation money to sign a real CB. And for that manner, a real LB as well.
        Hell, pick up some players who are currently out of contract if they want. It’s better than what they are currently doing.

      • The Black Hand says:

        I would love for the Union to sign a real CB, with their surplus of allocation money. Unfortunately, that would make our club stronger and that, for some reason, seems to be a no-no to our current management.

      • We are still susceptible to an aerial attack on set pieces. We need some size back there. I like the idea of Okugo playing some D. It makes much more sense to me than using Marfan in the back. Come to think of it whose freakin’ bright idea was it to play Marfan there anyway? He does not defend especially well. Gabe has played in Mexico so he’s got an edge to him. Michael…not so much.

      • The Black Hand says:

        I kind of liked Marfan back there, for the Red Bull match. He looked ok defensively and added to our attack as a wingback. He looked poor against Dallas, but that was true for the entire club. I would not object to another look at Marfan as a RB.

  5. Philly Cheese says:

    Although somewhat depressing to read analysis…..accurate evaluation of overall mess on display in Dallas. Trying to find a silver lining in one point instead of zero is only positive that comes to mind. Lahoud thrown onto field when he doesn’t even know the players names….much less their strengths and preferences is inexcusable coaching. How does that reward Okugo for three years of waiting for opportunity to show his abilities? I would prefer Hoffman/Mwanga/Martinez on field at same time if three forwards used in Toronto. Unfortunately, good game by Pajoy vs. Energy Drinks may guarantee him four consecutive starts whether he practices up to that level or not. Perhaps friendly game and second level games will let three forward “experiment” develop after Toronto.

  6. Piotr Nowak says:

    Ray! Love the things you’re doing on the pitch! In fact, I’m so impressed, I have a special surprise for ya! It’s really gona take your game to the next level! Your very own place on the bench! Don’t worry about any of that silly “playing” business. This is the new thing all the young people are doing…watching…watching your older, slower, less talented teammates play in your place.

    You’ve earned it bud! You’ve finally arrived!

    • James "4-3-3" Forever says:

      Hey Pete, How come you haven’t leveraged your history as both a player and a coach to bring in some decent Polish players for a our club? I thought forever that Smolarek would have been a great piece to bring in as a striker DP. And right now, I’m sure there are plenty of Polish CBs and LBs who would be decent in the MLS.

      • Philly Cheese says:

        That is a painful joke……you were joking, right?……..please tell me Union haven’t hired an Eastern Europe player development staff member, who used to be a player’s agent, who is Nowak’s second cousin on his mother’s side……..

      • My dream was that our DP signing to go with our first season would be Smolarek. Makes sense and he would have been fine in the MLS.

      • Piotr Nowak says:

        Yes, yes, James. Rest assured. Everything is going according to The Plan. We have a saying down on the Nowak pierogi farm that goes a little something like this, “One does not make sensical, ethical decisions when running a football team; instead one does the opposite.”

        So yes, your suggestion has been duly noted, and tested against the above sage advice, (sage advice passed down from generation in the Nowak family mind you), we will, in fact, be tapping my unbelievable resources back in the Motherland, to really make this a “team” we can all be proud of.

        But hey, if it doesn’t work out, at least the new kielbasa vendor I’m bringing to PPL will be good!

  7. This team is so broken. In game tactical decisions aside, what Nowak and the FO have done with this team is just depressing. It breaks my heart, because this season didnt have to be this way. Nowak and his crew have ruined this for me.

    I still want my home team to win, and I want to cheer them on forever. But man, this just sucks.

  8. Totally Agree with Ariel, I really really want to keep cheering on the team and buying shirts/scarves etc and go to games,but the way this season has become a mess so quickly it’s getting tougher and tougher.

    Preferred Lineup Vs Toronto (if kept in 4-3-3)
    Gaddis, Williams, Valdes, Garfan
    Okugo, Carroll, Marfan
    Adu, Mwanga, Herdling

    I think this would really provide significantly more offensive possibilities, while keeping Okugo and Caroll on to make sure there is some cover on defense. I’m tired of both Pajoy and Gomez. I would make the first subs off the bench Martinez, Pajoy and Daniel.

    Mwanga hasn’t showed much yet, but we’ll never know until he keeps getting starts. Herdling has looked good when given time, and Adu and Marfan could eat up people out on the wings.

    • snugsmac - rejects says:

      Like them or not Pajoy and Gomez have scored about ALL of our goals on the season, you will not see either of them out of the starting 11 any time soon.

  9. MikeRSoccer says:

    I am beginning to wonder if Gomez and Carrol are capable of playing together. Their styles of play and natural positions do not seem to mesh well and yet they are both so obviously talented that I, and I imagine Nowak as well, have this compulsion to see them both on the field. Bold Move to propose sitting Gomez for the next game as his injury appears to be only minor (Via Gomez Twiter) and his past antics when taken out of a game early leads me to believe that sitting him would probably result in a Spanish version of the Califf drama. Why not? We’ve already had French and English versions. It’s only natural that the next Nowakian clash would be Spanish.
    I don’t understand why Daniel played RW. Daniel was deputized as a LB for one game after the Harvey trade last summer and while clearly out of position he certainly seemed more comfortable and capable then Marfan has looked at RB. I simply don’t understand why Nowak decided to play Gaddis, Marfan and Daniel out of position when he could have played the left footed Daniel slightly out of position at LB and Gaddis and Marfan in their natural spots. Anyway, viva la 4-3-3. Hoping for MacMath Gaddis-Williams-Valdes-Garfan Marfan-Carroll-Daniel Adu-Mwanga-Pajoy. Perhaps this would be an acceptable time for Nowak to over exaggerate a player injury and choose to sit Gomez. At least Nowak can lie in a language the player doesn’t speak this time.

    • would like this lineup with gomez at CB, williams at RB, and Gaddis at LB. just curious how that would look.

      • I understand the curiosity but you want to move our leading goal scorer to CB?

      • MikeRSoccer says:

        The fact that Gomez is the teams leading goal scorer says more about our offense than it does about our defense. Valdes already scares me enough when he does one of his trademark midfield or beyond forays. Gomez would do the same thing, which would make two crazy CBs and probably a lot of getting caught out of position. Califf-Valdes was great because they complimented each other perfectly. The only reason why Gaddis has been successful at LB is because he is faster than anyone else he has come up against. I really don’t like the idea of playing with a weak sided back. Eventually teams are going to start to expose that and he will get into trouble.

  10. Kensington Josh says:

    Glad Califf got the win for Chivas. My take is Nowak puts Lahoud in to prove that he made a good trade.

    I hope you all see that we got beat on a set play, on a couple of headers, for the one goal we conceded. Maybe you watched the highlights and saw Califf track and head out a weighted pass from Beckham that would have been an assist otherwise.

    And maybe you’re where I’m at. I’d like the Union to lose until they change the way they treat players who work hard and do their best for the club. Yeah- this is the worst league for players in terms of how much control they have- but if you’re known as a bad boss, you don’t get good workers. And it belies the name union when management runs amok and there is no accountability.

  11. Pahotspur says:

    In all the time I have been around this game, and that is a good few years, whether it be the EPL or right down through the old forth division and for that matter even the minor league teams, never have I seen such a lack of cover in defense, a team playing so many players out of position, so little regard for a serious striker, or so many changes in formations week to week. I guess our Piotr thinks he has reinvented the game and that all those other managers who think a blend of youth and experience together with a consistent line up is a good thing, are wrong. Is there any team that succeeds who does not have a team leader? Instead we pay good money for ‘has-beens’ to sit on the bench. What was a golden opportunity to really establish The Union in year three has, at best, been put back a couple of years, at worst the fan base will lose interest. We have a terrific ground and a great fan base, so come on management let’s put a quality product on the pitch and grow this club so that we can have a 30,000 seat stadium!

    • The Black Hand says:

      This “Nowak” brand offers nothing to improve on. We rely on muddling up games and hoping to get lucky.

      • snugsmac - rejects says:

        This team is a god-damn car wreck….and every game is getting uglier and ugiler to watch…kind of like most of the chicks in the River End.

      • Eli Pearlman-Storch says:

        Snugs. Let’s keep the comments focused on the field, where I agree with your “uglier and uglier” assessment. Especially considering that your remark about female Union supporters is far from accurate, they do not deserve to bear the brunt of your ire.

  12. the kid union says:

    does anyone else think Jacobson looks older? like WAY older? like not three years older?

  13. Matt Kirk says:

    Although there have been jokes make in above about Nowak taking logical decisions and just doing the opposite, I feel as this is spot on. I mean his tactical and personnel decisions are just mind blowing, even at year 3 when I have learnt to expect the unexpected out of Nowak.
    I hate to see the Union lose and I never wish my team to lose but damn, when they win, it sure does not feel as great as it should. Losing seems the only way for Nowak to leave, well I hope thats what it means.
    It is just painful to watch these games. How can you not keep the same personnel and formation that did so well against Schalke 04?? There is no reason for this. How can a team develop chemistry with the crappy personnel changes that Nowak deploys? answer: they can not and it is driving not only the team into the ground but me insane as well. Just horrible managing from A to Z, Nowak just seems to enjoy killing any sort of team chemistry as soon as the players start to show some on the pitch.
    And for the love of pete can the Union handle their players with at least some sort of care?!? I mean how does the Union look appealing at all to other players? How can you expect to keep bringing in players with the horrible treatment of players departing. I understand trading players, professional soccer is a business just like every other sport but, the key word is professional and the Union are far from it with the way they handle their departing transfers/trades.
    Very disappointing, I think I have passed the anger phase of being a fan and just have generally become disappointed with the club/FO/Nowak.

    • Philly Cheese says:

      On any team at any level, morale is important. Perhaps Nowak can convince us that Califf trade was for the good of the future team…..but that would only work if he showed some honesty and leadership with other decisions made.
      I don’t know how long of a contract Nowak has with Union, but cost of any buyout is probably far beyond Union ability to pay to get a real coach.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *