Analysis / Union

A sober look at the Union’s playoff chances

Photo Ron Soliman

After the Philadelphia Union’s Leagues Cup tournament ends Sunday, the club’s difficult push to make the playoffs begins three days later on Wednesday.

Jim Curtin recently opined that they must win five of their remaining nine league games to qualify. Five wins would add 15 points to the current 27 to total 42. Last year 43 points qualified both Charlotte and Red Bull for the eastern conference wildcard game, a single elimination match between finishers eight and nine for the chance to play a “best of three home-away-home” series against the conference champion. The wildcard continues this year.

Eastern conference playoff situation

This chart clarifies  many realities about the eastern conference playoff situation. As of Thursday, August 22, Philadelphia is below the playoff line.

  • Columbus and New England have two games in hand over the rest of the conference, giving them the most intense among the intense frequencies of play.
  • The next 12 teams all have a game in hand over Toronto, who do not play on Decision Day and will also be finishing the Canadian Championship competition.
  • In Eastern Conference places nine through 14, Atlanta, Philadelphia, Montreal, Nashville, and D. C. are separated by only two points. The first tiebreaker is wins. The second is goal difference.

Playoffs Chances Analysis Chart

(before Saturday, August 24, 2024)

  Club Games left Pts now Max Pts Home Games Away Games
1 Miami 9 53 80 Cin; Phl; Char; NEng; Chi; Atl; NYC; Clmb; Tor;
2 Cincinnati 9 48 75 Mntl; Clmb; LAFC; Orl; Mia; Minn; Nsh; NYC; Phl;
3 Columbus 11 43 76 NYC; Sttl; Orl; Mia; Phl; NEng; Phl; Cin; Tor;  DC; NYRB;
4 NY Red Bull 9 41 68 Phl; KC; Atl; NYC; Clmb; Char; Chi; Tor; Atl;
5 NYC FC 9 38 65 Chi; Phl; Mia; NYRB; Cin; Nsh; Clmb; DC; Mntl;
6 Charlotte 9 37 64 NYRB; Atl; NEng; Chi; Mntl; Mntl; Orl; Mia; DC;
7 Orlando 9 34 61 Nsh; NEng; Char; Phl; Atl; KC; Clmb; Dal; Cin;
8 Toronto 8 30 54 DC; Aust; Clmb; NYRB; Mia; Hou; Colo; Chi;
9 Atlanta 9 28 55 Nsh; Mia; Mntl; NYRB; LAGX; Char; NYRB; Phl; Orl;
Playoff line
10 Philadelphia 9 27 54 Clmb; DC; Atl; Cin NYRB; Mia; NYC; Orl; Clmb;
11 Montreal 9 27 54 NEng; Char; Chi; SJ; NYC; Cin; NEng; Atl; Char;
12 Nashville 9 26 53 Aus; Chi; Cin; DC; Orl; Atl; NEng; NYC; Chi;
13 D. C. 9 26 53 Dal; NYC; Clmb; Char; Tor; Chi; Phl; Nsh; NEng;
14 Chicago 9 25 52 Mia; DC; NYRB; Tor; Nsh; NYC; Nsh; Mntl; Char;
15 New England 11 23 56 StL; Mntl; Nsh; DC; Mntl; SLC; Orl; Char; Hou; Clmb; Mia;
The Union’s chances

These different factors affect the Union’s chances.

  • Injuries and suspensions.
  • International absences.
  • Game frequency.
  • Quality of opponents.

The injury variable is difficult to predict. Excessive fatigue is a controllable threat, especially among older players and those who are recovering from previous injuries and surgeries. August 28 to October 19 is too long a time to be sustained by adrenaline. (See game frequency discussion below.)

Suspensions are comparable to injuries, although usually shorter.

After  identifying all Union international call-ups over the last twelve months and the schedules of those players’ international teams (Senior, U23, U20, U17, and U15), we conclude that the Union will suffer no  international absences during its September and October regular season games.

The same cannot be predicted were they to make a deep playoff run into mid-November. UEFA Nations League, Concacaf Nations League, and CONMEBOL’s World Cup Qualification will be playing, and the details of playoff scheduling are too variable to predict that the playoffs can avoid the November international window. (Post publication note: the day after publication MLS released the playoff schedule and they do avoid he November window as well.)

Only the playoffs’ start on October 23, and the MLS Cup final on December 7 are known exactly. (Click here for currently known MLS playoff details . The website gives the Union’s chances for making the eighth or ninth seeds as 10% and 12% respectively.)

Game frequency is a challenge the Union faces in trying to win at least five games. Since a game is a 90-minute effort no matter the competition, starting from the end of the Leagues Cup group stage, here is the Union’s past and future game frequency. Leagues Cup matches are asterisked*. “Days since previous match” is the key column.

# Day Date Opponent Days since previous match Result
Sun 4-Aug Cruz Azul* 8th day D 1-1 (p)
Fri 9-Aug Montreal* 5th day W 2-0
Tue 13-Aug @Cincinnati* 4th day W 4-2
Sat 17-Aug Mazatlan* 4th day D 1-1 (p)
1 Wed 21-Aug @Columbus* 4th day L 3-1
2 Sun 25-Aug Colorado* 4th day
3 Wed 28-Aug Columbus 3rd day
4 Sat 31-Aug @NY Red Bull 3rd day
FIFA September International Window
5 Sat 14-Sep @Miami 14th day
6 Wed 18-Sep @NYC FC 4th day
7 Sun 22-Sep D. C. 4th day
8 Sat 28-Sep Atlanta 6th day
9 Wed 2-Oct @Orlando 4th day
10 Sat 5-Oct @Columbus 3rd day
FIFA October International Window
11 Sat 19-Oct Cincinnati 14th day
12 We 23-Oct Playoff Wild Card 4th day

Jim Curtin’s recent public emphasis on the depth of his squad makes emphatic sense. He will need it. Current midfielders must stay in Philly until season’s end. Fortunately, the transfer windows are now, or soon will be, closed.

The Union finishes against a strong array of opponents. Of their last nine regular season ones, only D. C. does not lie above the playoff line. They play Columbus twice in the most prominent example of the challenge. It will be an achievement if they qualify for the wild card game.

5 Comments

  1. A good write-up. Too bad it’s like analyzing the chances of the Cleveland Browns making the playoffs. It doesn’t matter because their chances of winning the Super Bowl are zero.
    . . .
    We need to get it across to Sugarman to get the barbed wire out of his pockets and take winning championships seriously. That means big moves in the off-season or else. So long as he believes that we will pay just the same, he’ll keep doing what he’s doing.

    • Will not happen with this ownership collective. And they sound like they are in it for the long haul, always have.
      .
      From the longest term widest perspective possible, they may be trying to prove an alternative to the financial irresponsibility that dominated soccer everywhere else. If true it would be a worthy goal, but I cannot confirm that it is a goal.
      .
      It was clear from a quiet comment at least a year ago that the possibility of a financially responsible model intrigues Ernst Tanner.

  2. Nice article, Tim. Sobering indeed

    Man, that international break in Oct is gonna be an interest killer when they’re already eliminated.

    Personally, I’ve the potential to go a full season without going to a match, the first since 2010. I usually do the last match, a comp from my company. Mercifully, I’ve a trip scheduled that weekend.

    Looking forward to late January news of some Central European diamond in the rough tagged as our new, exciting player.

  3. Thank you, Tim. Very good analysis, as always. I agree with your conclusion.
    .
    Another variable might be the Home/Away factor, including distance and relationship to the “days since previous match.” But a quick look at it made me think it’s not going to matter as much everything you already cited.

  4. Of course as soon as the piece gets published, MLS releases the playoff schedule.
    .
    There will be no conflicts between the FIFA’s November window and MLS’s playoffs. none. Only travel time remains as a possibility.
    .
    This time Round 1, aka the conference quarterfinals, a best of three event, occurs before the November window. The conference semifinals occur after it, as do the conference finals and MLS Cup.
    .
    Participating teams will have to figure out how to stay sharp during the November break.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*