Union match reports

Match Report: Philadelphia Union – 1 vs. 2 – New England Revolution

Photo courtesy of the Kevin Barrett/Philly Soccer Page

The Philadelphia Union looked to get back to winning ways after their 2-2 draw with Charlotte on Saturday, while the New England Revolution in third place at the start of the game needed points to assure home field advantage. The Boys in Blue would be without Cavan Sullivan for the first time in 14 games. It would be a difficult game, and it brought an end to the Union’s unbeaten streak.

First Half

The Union came out on the front foot, pinning the Revs back during the early minutes and looking dangerous. Vassilev and Quinn Sullivan combined to overload the left. The engine of the Revs’ attack, Carles Gil, was forced to drop deep. The Union had the better chances early in the game. In the third minute, Quinn Sullivan saw his shot beat Matt Turner in goal but skid harmlessly across the crossbar. In the 10th minute, after some scrappy play from a free kick, the final chance fell weakly to Turner. But as the game developed, Gill began to find space and willing runners in between the lines.

The match ranged end to end. Blake was called into action in the 27th minute, saving a strike from Luca Langoni, and moments later, at the other end, Iloksi fired a low shot that went just wide. But New England was finding ways in between defenders, and Blake was forced into another save in the 42nd minute from a snap shot by former teammate, Daniel Gazdag. Indiana Vassilev saw his shot blocked by Ilay Feingold barely a minute later. Then, in the 45+3rd minute of stoppage, after a poorly defended series, Turgeman found the net at the back post to give the Revolution a 0-1 lead going into the half.

Second Half

The union came out needing to be more clinical in front of goal, and they found joy down the flanks, first through Danley Jean Jacques on the right, and then Vassilev on the left. But the Union attacks were marred by uncharacteristically poor passing and miscommunication. What might have been dangerous crosses into the box were easily cut out by Turner in goal. New England’s Langoni was dangerous in attack, finding a hole in the Union defense and forcing Blake into another save.

The parade of physios continued from the first half, when in the 49th and 69th minutes they were called onto the field for the fifth and sixth times to attend to head injuries. In the 80th minute they were called in again when Wynder took out Neil Pierre as he sped down the right flank.

In the 67th minute Anello was subbed in for Vassilev. The Union attacks, while promising, did not result in a goal. In the 72nd minute, Blake was called to make another strong save. In the 82nd minute, Richter subbed off Harriel for Jakupovic to try to add a spark or some bite to the attack. But the promising buildups and runs continued without a final product. In the 90th minute, referee Malik Badawi went to the monitor and reversed an offside call on the Rev’s Carles Gil, who Pierre was adjudged to have fouled in the box. The resulting penalty kick from Gil went in. 0-2, New England.

The final minutes were hectic–and there were 12 minutes of added time. But it looked like the Union would be shut out. Until the 106th minute when Kai Wagner saved a ball off the endline and sent it across. Neil Pierre rose and nodded it home. For the final minutes. the Boys in Blue sent in wave after wave, but the score at the final whistle was the Union 1, New England 2.

The Union travels next to face Nashville on Wednesday, October 28, with kickoff scheduled for 8:30 p.m. ET on Apple TV.

Three Points

  • Missing Cavan: The Union attack looked too predictable, and defenders were able for the most part to hold their positions. Richter deserves credit for making subs when he had to, but he was missing the depth of Bueno and Cavan Sullivan.
  • Andre Blake: Remains one of the best keepers in the league. This game could have been very lopsided
  • Striking woes: There was no final product until Neil Pierre’s goal deep in stoppage time.

Philadelphia Union (4-4-2):

Andre Blake; Kai Wagner, Nathan Harriel (Malik Jakupovic 82′), Neil Pierre, Frankie Westfield; Jovan Lukić, Danley Jean Jacques, Indiana Vassilev (Augistin Anello 67′), Quinn Sullivan; Bruno Damiani, Milan Iloski

Unused Substitutes: Japhet Sery Larsen, Alejandro Bedoya, Jeremy Rafanello, Ben Bender, Ezekiel Alladoh; Kellan LeBlanc, , Andrew Rick

New England Revolution (4-3-3): 

Matt Turner, Ilay Feingold, Ethan Kohler, Josh Wynder, Peyton Miller, Matthew Polster, Luca Langoni; Cales Gil, Jackson Yeill, Daniel Gazdag, Dor Turgerman

Unused Substitutes:  Mamadu Fofana, Tanner Beason, Griffin Yow, Cody Baker, Brooklyn Raines, Wilson Harris; Donovan Parisian, Judah Siqueira, Diego Fagundez

Scoring Summary:

NE: Turgeman – 45+3′

NE: Gill – (PK) – 90′

PHI: Neil Pierre (Kai Wagner) – 106′

Officials:

Malik Badawi (Ref.), Chris Elliott (AR1), Kevin Klinger (AR2), Ricardo Montero Araya (4th); Michael Radchuck (VAR), Mike Kampmeinert (AVAR)

Disciplinary Summary:

63′ – Damiani, yellow card

65′ – Lukic, yellow card

 

18 Comments

  1. A couple of corrections. It was only 4 games since they were without Cavan (when he was with the national team when they beat Orlando).. And I’m pretty sure Pierre’s goal was earlier than 106 minutes. More like 102nd minute (unless you are adding on the 4 minutes of first half stoppage time to the count).
    .
    A pretty poor effort by the entire team except Blake. 23 shots but only 7 on target on most of those straight to the keeper just isn’t going to do it. And Damiani managed to get himself suspended for what looked like dissent.
    .
    Hopefully New England will win on Wednesday so the Union clinch a spot in the playoffs.

  2. I think that yellow means Damiani or for the next game

  3. Without Cavan, back to the cross and hope Union against a good team that doesn’t turn the ball over against the press. Hopefully the FO sees this and learns that if they want to win a trophy in the future, a playmaking #10 that can beat a defender 1v1 is a must. Because without one, the team is a high floor/low ceiling club that will never win a trophy.

    • The club has always known that, but we’ll wait until Saint Never’s Day unless Sugarman sells the club, which is probably a similar wait. He’ll never buy that kind of player and will always sell them.

      • Sad but true. No depth, big surprise. The FO brought Wagner back and that’s it for this year. They didn’t reload for a Cup run, because they do not aspire for it as a priority. They win, but don’t care if they don’t win it all. It’s so obvious.

  4. Missing Cavan certainly exhibited itself tonight. He’s an aggressive high risk/high reward player with abilities above MLS levels in fine touch, field vision, sequencing, and crisp through balls. He’s simply able to provide better service to our MLS level guys, which in turn creates improved production from them (and in Damiani’s case, a remarkable difference). Without him, we were klunkier tonight, and against the current No. 2 seed, fatally so.

  5. Charlotte showed everyone how to slow down the Union offense, and New England added “The Physio Card” to complete the picture against us for the playoffs. “Head Coach” Ritcher MUST change things up against Nashville and FCC… and hopefully we get Miami in the first round. They’re so arrogant, the kids can beat them.

  6. As others have said the attack was just too predictable. I also noticed that there were very few crosses aimed at changing the sideline attack. Far too much play just down one flank or the other. Many times the 2 guys opposite the ball were unmarked and had plenty of space. So that’s on the coaches to adjust for. Missing Bueno and C. Sullivan was evident. On to the next 2 then a hopeful playoff run.

    It’s the hope that kills ya!!

  7. TheBallDontLie

    Carles Gil is ageless and an incredible field general for the Revs. His ability to manipulate defenders and possess is special. Screw that guy.

  8. The Fall chill was in the air at Subaru Park on Saturday night. The stadium seemed to be about 85% full for the Union’s very important game against New England. Here is the view from Section 105:
    1) If you had a question about the importance of Cavan Sullivan to the 2026 version of the Union, it was answered last night. This is his team, and they will only go so far as he takes them. His creativity was sorely missed last night.
    2) Carlos Gil, MOTM, is a very, very good player. Perhaps it is a measure of how good Spanish soccer is that he has not been called up to the national team, though he has great skills and timing on both sides of the ball. Just as the Union are Cavan Sullivan’s team, the Revolution are Carlos Gil’s team, and they will only go so far as he takes them. He took them to victory last night.
    3) As a team, New England are very disciplined defensively, and Matt Turner is an excellent positional goalkeeper. The Union’s crosses nearly always ended up in Turner’s arms because he read the plays correctly. The Union put a lot of crosses into the penalty area, but the vast majority of them posed no danger.
    4) The Union did play with urgency for the last 20 minutes of regular time in the second half and in extra time, and I give them and Coach Richter full credit for that. The team has embraced a “no quit” culture, which as a supporter, I appreciate no matter what the result.
    5) The outcome of this match was determined by the officiating, which in my judgment, had been pretty wildly inconsistent throughout the match. If you are reading this, you probably know exactly what the situation was at the end of regulation time: The Union were pressing with 2 or so minutes to go in regular time. Carlos Gil, who was stationed near the halfway line made a run and received a pass 10 yards past Neil Pierre, the Union’s last defender on that side. As Gil entered the penalty area, Pierre went to ground and fouled him without touching the ball. The AR on our side raised the offside flag, and we thought that was the end of things—if Gil was offside, then the foul, which occurred later, was of no moment. However, after a very lengthy review, the referee announced the Gil was “not offside” and awarded a penalty, which pretty much decided the game. No replay of any sort was shown on the screen to those of us in attendance.

    This morning, I looked at the Crapple version of the event. The alleged VAR that was shown by Crapple was a very long shot from a poor angle. From that view, two things were pretty obvious: a) Gil’s foot was on the halfway line (onside); b) because Gil’s shoulder was ahead of his foot in receiving the pass, it looked to be slightly offside. Thus, if there was an error, it was not “clear and obvious,” especially since the review took 5 minutes. For those of you who follow the Union closely, this was the same situation as when the Union faced Cincinnati in a playoff game a few years ago and no offiside was determined because the error was not “clear and obvious.”

    This system stinks. First of all, offside is a binary determination—either a player is onside or offside—it is not a question of judgment, it is a question of the quality of review. If we are going to review offsides determinations at all, then we should have high quality video equipment and computer equipment to do so.
    6) Credit to the Union for persisting and scoring in stoppage time—it showed big time character and they very nearly pulled out a draw.
    7) This is my last comment on the officiating, having watched 3 youth matches (2 at the middle school level and one at the travel team level) and this match this week. I saw referees issue 3 yellow cards for “dissent.” On Friday, the referee of the middle school game issued a yellow card to one of my grandson’s teammates for something that the player said—not a contact to an opponent. My grandson asked the referee why he gave him a yellow card and he got one, too, for questioning the first card being issued. Flash forward to the issuance of the yellow card to Bruno Damiani for “dissent.” I could not hear what was being said. However, I could see that Bruno was neither yelling nor remonstrating against the referee in any non-verbal way when the card was issued. As usual, Bruno was on the receiving end of much contact by the opponent, some of which was determined to be a foul and some of which was not. The best referees in the world almost never issue yellow cards for dissent because they talk with the players and they are confident in their abilities to police the match. It has been my sad experience that the least able referees are those who most often issue yellow cards for “dissent,” and I do not like it.

    • The Union did not lose because of the officiating, they lost because over 2/3 of their shots were off target and most of the rest were right to Matt Turner.
      .
      I was surprised the AR raised his flag because I thought the play was onside watching it live from 127.
      .
      Regardless of what Bruno said, it’s his on fault for even putting himself in a position to get a card when he was only one away from suspension. Players have to learn not to give the ref the chance to show them a yellow in a situation like that.

      • The determination of Gil’s offside/onside was VERY tight, and the AR did well to keep the flag down until the play concluded. I would be interested in your thoughts after looking at the Crapple replay. My point is that, unlike Premier League, which has first-rate technology, MLS apparently does not (at least that which was shown on Crapple). I thought that in MLS, only “clear and obvious” calls were to be reversed by VAR–this was not one of them.

        Re: Bruno–you are correct. Players need to be aware of the potential for suspension and “mind their manners.” From Section 105, it appeared that whatever Bruno said was not done in a way to show the ref up. I do not think that yellow cards given for dissent should count towards suspensions, dangerous fouls should.

  9. I don’t want to disparage Quinn but he and Frankie don’t have the same chemistry as Cavan. Or maybe he was off. But over and over they played the same pattern.. never played the overlap, always coming inside then back out for the cross. Never taking anyone one on one. Even then, with as bad a performance across the board as it was, there were enough chances to take something from this game. Iloski wants that one back. Danley 2-3 times. Ugh.

  10. .Thought the game was over at 2-0. At least Richter has reinstilled a never give up philosophy back into the team this year. Hoping Cavan returns soon and is not distracted by USMNT duties.Phily teams cant seem to get a break on. the injury bug when things look promising. A Deep playoff run is still a strong possibility if Cavan returns healthy and stays focussed on the Union A. Cup run would be amazing based on this remarkable 2nd half turn around. I personally would be more satisfied to face Miami and beat Messi and company in the playoffs in Miami. I Cant stand their fans ,the city or the preferential BS calls that always go in Messis favor . The officiating when Messi plays is always biased.

  11. Rules Novice

    I agree with the comment above about Gil appearing to be offside (shoulder) in the run that led to the penalty. It certainly was not a “clear and obvious error”. But I need some help with what followed from you rules experts. Pierre clearly fouled Gil and it was clear that it occurred just inside the box. But before the foul, the ball had been released by Gil with quite a bit of momentum. Studying the replay, there is absolutely no way that Gil, if he stayed on his feel, would have been able to reach the ball before it crossed the end line. In fact, the ball appeared to be very close to crossing the end line by the time Gil was fouled. Isn’t there something in the soccer rules comparable to the “uncatchable pass” rule in American football, which eliminates the possibility of pass interference if the pass is could not reasonably have been caught by the receiver?

    • You pose a good question, and the answer is no, there is no analog. Unlike USA football, physical contact with an opponent is not the expected norm in soccer. Physical contact is OK so long as it occurs during an attempt to play the ball (which is why shouldering an opponent for position is generally allowed). Physical contact with an opponent without an attempt to play the ball is a foul, but most referees do not call minor shirt tugs, pushes, etc., especially when such do not affect the flow of play. The problem with Pierre’s slide tackle of Gil was the degree of force used. If the tackle does not hit the ball before the opponent’s foot, ankle or leg, it generally will result in a yellow card (and frankly, I was surprised that Pierre did not get a yellow card in addition to the award of the penalty). I have seen penalties called during corner kicks when a defender tackles an opposing player who may not have had any chance of scoring.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*